
FALL RIVER ─ The Massachusetts Peace Officer Standards and Training Commission (POST) on Thursday closed its inquiry into alleged misconduct by former Fall River Police Chief Paul Gauvin, ending a more than two-year fight by the nearly 30-year veteran to remain a Fall River police officer.
“I’m very pleased that P.O.S.T. has concluded its review and affirmed my certification. It’s been a long road, and I’m grateful to finally put this chapter behind me and focus on what matters most: serving the men and women of the Fall River Police Department and the community,” Gauvin said in an email to the Fall River Reporter. (Read Gauvin’s full statement at the end of this story.)
In a Thursday letter to Gauvin’s attorney, POST’s Division of Police Standards wrote that it “has closed its preliminary inquiry into your alleged misconduct and that the Commission has elected not to commence disciplinary proceedings against you.”
“In light of this disposition, there will be no further proceedings in this matter,” wrote POST enforcement counsel Amy C. Parker.
The letter said the decision was based on “the unique circumstances of your case” and is not meant as precedent for other matters. Interim Police Chief J.T. Hoar was copied on it.
The same day, POST renewed Gauvin’s certification as a law enforcement officer without any limitation, condition or restriction, according to a Notice of Certification dated Nov. 19 and signed by Steven R. Smith, POST’s director of police certification. The certification runs through Jan. 1, 2029.
Gauvin said he will be back on duty Monday.
Chief J.T. Hoar did not immediately respond to a request for information on Gauvin’s return to the department.
Second state ruling in Gauvin’s favor
POST is the second state agency to rule in Gauvin’s favor since the city let him go in 2025. The administration of Mayor Paul Coogan ended Gauvin’s contract as chief on March 31, 2025, and fired him as a captain on April 21, 2025.
The department’s police unions announced a vote of no confidence in Gauvin in late summer 2024. In October 2024, Gauvin reached an agreement with Coogan to step down as chief and return to the rank of captain.
Kelly Furtado, then a captain, was sworn in as interim chief on Oct. 15, 2024. She said she found a knife and a bullet in a desk drawer in the chief’s office on her first day, and three guns not registered to Gauvin were found in his station locker days later, the Reporter has reported.
The city hired Comprehensive Investigations and Consulting, headed by former state Secretary of Public Safety Daniel Bennett, on Dec. 16, 2024, and placed Gauvin on paid administrative leave the next day. The firm’s 90-page report detailed 15 policy violations, including allegations of harassment and intimidation, and Coogan cited its recommendations when he fired Gauvin.
The City Council rejected Furtado’s appointment as permanent chief twice in April 2025 before approving it 5-4 on May 13, 2025, with a one-year contract.
Furtado went out on medical leave in April 2026 amid friction with the City Council, then retired. She has since notified the city and the City Council that she intends to sue under the state’s whistleblower law.
Gauvin appealed his firing to the Massachusetts Civil Service Commission and won. On Aug. 6, the commission reduced the firing to a 90-day suspension and ordered him reinstated as a Fall River police officer.
The commission upheld two findings: that Gauvin never recorded the guns or turned them in to the evidence room, and that he left the knife and bullet in the drawer. It found the drawer was neglect, not an effort to intimidate Furtado, and it rejected the harassment, compensatory-time and photograph charges.
Gauvin has been paid a captain’s salary since August while on paid leave. He is still owed back pay and benefits for the time he lost after his firing, which the Reporter estimated in October at more than $202,000.
Gauvin’s full statement
“I’m very pleased that P.O.S.T has concluded its review and affirmed my certification. It’s been a long road, and I’m grateful to finally put this chapter behind me and focus on what matters most: serving the men and women of the Fall River Police Department and the community. Throughout my nearly 30-year career, I’ve always believed that good leadership requires accountability, resilience, self-awareness, and, above all, emotional maturity. Those qualities matter just as much in policing as they do in leadership. I’ve always said the windshield is bigger than the rearview mirror, and that’s where my focus is today. I’m looking forward to what lies ahead.”
“That said, moving forward shouldn’t mean overlooking what happened or the lessons that need to be learned. I believe the City owes it to its employees and its residents to take an honest look at how this process unfolded. Two independent adjudicatory bodies reached conclusions that differed significantly from the City’s original findings. That should give anyone pause and raise some important questions. Was the process truly objective from beginning to end? Were conclusions reached before all the facts were fairly considered? Did preconceived notions or other motives influence how the allegations were investigated and evaluated? These aren’t questions that should be dismissed or avoided. If mistakes were made, City leadership should acknowledge them, understand how they happened, and take steps to ensure they don’t happen to another city employee. We’ve all invested far too much time, money, and energy in this ordeal for the City to simply double down rather than learn something from it.”







