Top 10 Fall River mom and pop pizza places ranked for 2025; did your favorites make the cut?

Based on available information from reviews, ratings, and local sentiment, here’s a ranked list of the top 10 pizza places in Fall River.

Rankings consider factors such as pizza quality, crust, toppings, service, and overall reputation.

Sam’s Pizza 144 Rodman St.

Why it ranks #1: Frequently praised for its greasy, cheesy, full-flavored pies with a variety of styles (Italian, American, Portuguese, Greek-inspired). The Shrimp Alfredo and Melanzane (eggplant parmesan-inspired) pizzas are standout specialties. Reviewers highlight the perfect balance of crust and toppings, plus a casual, friendly vibe.

Highland Pizza 797 Robeson St

Why it ranks #2: A decades-old institution celebrated for its Neapolitan and Greek-style pies. The Chourico Pizza with Portuguese sausage and kalamata olives is a fan favorite. Even cold, the pizza holds up, a testament to its quality.

Eastern Pizza 1196 Bedford St

Why it ranks #3: Known for heavy, topping-loaded pizzas with a crispy Greek-style crust. The Fall River Hawaiian (chourico and pineapple) and Portuguese pizzas are local hits. Fast delivery and fresh ingredients make it a go-to for many.

Fiorentina Italian Kitchen 1833 N Main St

Why it ranks #4: Offers NY-style and Italian-inspired pizzas with fresh, made-to-order ingredients. The Ciao Bella and Cyprus pizzas are highly rated in taste tests. A local landmark for its pasta and pizza combo.

Pizza Time 1539 Pleasant St

Why it ranks #5: Praised for rivaling NY pizza, with standout specialty pies like the Socrates Pizza (grilled toppings) and Buffalo Chicken. Consistent delivery and fresh sides like seafood salad add to its appeal. Greek-style but with a unique flair.

New England Pizza 345 Robeson St

Why it ranks #6: A Highlands favorite known for homemade dough and sauce recipes. The pizza is flavorful, with a wide menu including subs and wraps.

Dave’s Pizza 873 Globe St

Why it ranks #7: Excels in specialty pizzas like Chicken Mozambique and Backyard BBQ. The crust is crispy yet soft, and toppings are fresh. Friendly staff and a diverse menu (salads, sandwiches) make it a solid choice.

Millennium Pizza 287 Broadway

Why it ranks #8: Offers top-quality ingredients with a perfectly crisp yet doughy crust. The cozy atmosphere and craft beer selection elevate the experience. Reviewers rave about the pepperoni, mushroom, and onion pies.

Boston Pizza & Seafood 210 Tucker St

Why it ranks #9: A reliable spot for both pizza and seafood, with hot, fresh pies and good deals. The Chicken Cobb salad is a surprising highlight, but the pizza holds its own in taste tests.

Atlas Pizza 761 Pleasant St

Why it ranks #10: A hidden gem with authentic, flavorful Greek-style pizzas, Atlas is known for its chourico and green pepper pie. The fresh ingredients and bold flavors keep customers coming back.

What are your favorites?