Father Jay Mello will not be returning as Pastor to St. Michael and St. Joseph Parishes in Fall River after investigation

FALL RIVER — The Diocese of Fall River announced today the conclusion of the investigation into allegations of sexual misconduct (none involving a minor) by Father Jay Mello. 

Following a thorough investigation, the Ministerial Review Board of the Diocese of Fall River, (a board composed of mostly lay people), evaluated the evidence and made recommendations to Bishop Edgar M. da Cunha, S.D.V. After his own independent review of the information gathered in the investigation and after considering the recommendations of the Ministerial Review Board, Bishop da Cunha has determined that some, though not all, of the allegations were credible, including credible allegations that Father Mello abused his position of power as a priest and engaged in sexual misconduct with two parishioners he was counseling.

The Diocese stated that not all ministerial misconduct is criminal, and the term also includes violations of professional standards and pastoral care.

Exact details of the misconduct were not released.

Father Mello will not be returning as Pastor to St. Michael and St. Joseph Parishes in Fall River, and he currently remains restricted from priestly ministry.

“This investigation has been difficult for many in our Diocesan community,” said Bishop da Cunha, “and especially for those who have been harmed by clergy abuse and misconduct. My prayer is that the conclusion of the investigation can bring some closure and healing to the St. Michael’s and St, Joseph’s Parishes.”

Mello was placed on administrative leave in June of last year by the bishop after the Diocese of Fall River received concerning information alleging sexual misconduct by the priest involving an adult.

An initial investigation by the Diocese found that there was sufficient evidence to warrant further investigation to determine whether Father Mello had violated the standards of ministerial behavior and the Code of Conduct for Priests.  Based on the allegations and the initial findings, Father Mello was placed on administrative leave as the investigation continues. Consistent with Diocesan standards, he is no longer residing at the parish rectory and has been directed to refrain from exercising public priestly ministry. 

At the time the Saint Micheal School community gathered not in protest but in peaceful expression, unified in their care for their children and dedication to restoring trust. Many parents and parishioners felt that the delay in communication had a profound impact, particularly on the children who formed close bonds with Father Jay.

As one parent expressed, “Our children deserve a community rooted in openness and support.
This demonstration is our way of coming together respectfully, showing our care and concern for one another during this uncertain time.”

Through its Victim Assistance Outreach, the Diocese of Fall River offers supportive services to victims of clergy abuse and misconduct and their families as well as to parishes impacted by this case. For assistance, please contact Carolyn Shipp, the Director of Safe Environment and Victim Assistance Coordinator at 508-985-6508 (confidential voicemail) or cshipp@dioc-fr.org.